Springsteen: Silence Is Unpatriotic
Springsteen: Silence Is Unpatriotic
Rock Star Answers Critics Who Say His Anti-War Album Is Unpatriotic | CBS 60 Minutes
It's hard to imagine, but Bruce Springsteen turned 58 last year. His breakout hit, "Born to Run," is 32 years old. While rock stars his age are content to tour with their greatest hits, Springsteen launched what may become his most controversial work ever as a songwriter.
Even now, Springsteen is an artist in progress, having moved from stories about girls and cars to populist ballads that echo the dust bowl days of Woody Guthrie. Springsteen has put all that together now in his first tour with the E Street Band in four years. As correspondent Scott Pelley first reported last fall, he has returned to full-throated rock and roll, and a message that's sharper than ever, damning the war in Iraq, and questioning whether America has lost its way at home.
Springsteen told 60 Minutes his concert is part circus, dance party, political rally, and big tent revival. "You're the shaman, you know? You're the storyteller. You're the magician. The idea is whatever the ticket price, we're supposed to be there to deliver something that can't be paid for. That's our job," Springsteen says.
"You have got to be, wild guess, worth somewhere north of 100 million dollars. Why are you still touring? You don't have to do this," Pelley remarks.
"What else would I do? You got any clues?" Springsteen asks. "Got any suggestions? I mean, am I going to garden? Why would you stop. I mean, you play the music and you know, grown men cry. And women dance. That's why you do it."
"It's good to be a rock star," Pelley says.
"I would say that yes it is," Springsteen says. "But the star thing I can live with. The music I can't live without. And that's how it lays out for me, you know. I got as big an ego and enjoy the attention. My son has a word, he calls it 'Attention Whore.'"
"But you have to be one of those or else why would you be up in front of thousands of people, you know, shaking your butt. But at the same time, when it comes down to it, it's the way it makes you feel. I do it because of the way it makes me feel when I do it. It gives me meaning, it gives me purpose," Springsteen explains.
"Some of the pieces in the new record are gonna be considered controversial. Give me a sense of what you think has to be said. Why are you still writing?" Pelley asks,
"It's how I find out who you are, and who I am, and then who we are. I'm interested in that. I'm interested in what it means to be an American," Springsteen says. "I'm interested in what it means to live in America. I'm interested in the kind of country that we live in and leave our kids. I'm interested in trying to define what that country is. I got the chutzpa or whatever you want to say to believe that if I write a really good about it, it's going to make a difference. It’s going to matter to somebody." To do that this time, he gathered up his nearly life-long friends in one of the most successful neighborhood bands ever, the E Street Band, named for the road where they used to rehearse. His wife of 16 years, Patti Scialfa, plays guitar. They have three teenagers back home.
Their reunions start where they first met, in Asbury Park, N.J. For a rock band, it's all very businesslike; rehearsal starts at 9 a.m.
There are more than 250 songs in the Springsteen repertoire. That's what makes rehearsals, like the one Pelley watched, so critical. Before each concert, maybe just an hour before, Springsteen writes by hand the list of songs, and their order. He changes it every night. But at least one song is always there, so familiar to the band that all he has to write on the list is "B-to-R," as in "Born to Run."
E Street keyboardist Roy Bittan and guitarist Steve van Zandt go back with Springsteen more than 30 years.
Do they hate playing "Born to Run" over and over again?
"It's funny you said that because I was watching something on TV. And it was Tony Bennett. And they asked Tony Bennett, 'Aren't you tired of singing I Left My Heart In San Francisco?' And his answer was, 'It gave me the keys to the world,'" Bittan says. "Well there it is, that's it."
"I figure if we do a few more tours I might actually learn it," van Zandt says, laughing. "So, you know. I mean, we live in hope, right?"
Humor helps if you’re an E-Streeter, because in the 1980s, Springsteen walked away from them after more than 15 years together. He wanted to play with other musicians, and sometimes with none at all.
"How was the news broken? Did Bruce tell the band himself? Tell me about it," Pelley says.
"I think Bruce picked up the phone and called everybody. And I think everybody was shocked and, I'm hurt. And just felt really abandoned," Bittan recalls.
"Was that hard? Was it heartbreaking? You say, 'Look, I'm going on. I'm leaving you behind,'" Pelley asks Springsteen.
"Well, I didn't exactly put it like that," Springsteen says, laughing.
Asked how he put it, Springsteen says, laughing, "I soft-soaped it somehow. Or I tried, you know? And, you know, everybody had different feelings. I mean people were mad or angry and suddenly they're okay. I wasn't going to be any good to them at that moment. You know? And I think what happens is sometimes you got to break your own narrative."
"We all have stories we're living and telling ourselves," he says, laughing. "And there's a time when that narrative has to be broken because you've run out of freedom in it. You've run out of places to go."
The split forced the band to find other places to go. Van Zandt joined the mob on "The Sopranos" on HBO, and drummer Max Weinberg joined Conan O’Brien on NBC. But they always drop what they’re doing to return to Springsteen.
60 Minutes watched the band do a small rehearsal out of the new material before an audience of 2,000 or so in Asbury Park. There’s something special about a Springsteen audience: they know the words, and the stories they feel in themselves. This was the day after Bruce’s 58th birthday, and Pelley found him immediately after the show, wringing wet.
"What did you learn about the band tonight?" Pelley asks.
"We made fewer screw ups than I thought we might. The main thing you learn is not so much the band, because the band will just play better from tonight on out. You know? But you learn a lot about the set, you know, you're trying to work your new things in. You're trying to get in what you're trying to say. You're trying to get people just to rock. You know, to go crazy and have fun. It's ultimately sort of supposed to be a bit of an ecstatic experience," Springsteen says.
Was it?
"And we got there a few times. It's pretty good," Springsteen says, laughing. "And so, you're trying to figure out, 'Okay, now how do you take it up to a certain height? And how do you get there?'"
"Pretty good for 58," Pelley remarks.
"Oh. That's nothing. I'm still a chiseled hunk of muscle so...I guess I'll keep going for a while," Springsteen says, laughing.
Springsteen's music career began over four decades earlier as a teenager in Freehold, N.J.
"I was probably one of the smartest kids in my class at the time. Except you would've never known it," Springsteen says, laughing. "You would've never known it. Because where my intelligence lay was not, wasn't able to be tapped within that particular system. And I didn't know how to do it myself until music came along and opened me up not just to the world of music but to the world period, you know, to the events of the day. To the connection between culture and society and those were things that riveted me, engaged me in life," Springsteen says. "Gave me a sense of purpose. What I wanted to do. Who I wanted to be. The way that I wanted to do it. What I thought I could accomplish through singing songs."
"It's not just the singing. It's the writing, isn't it, for you?" Pelley asks.
"Of course. Every good writer or filmmaker has something eating at them, right? That they can't quite get off their back . And so your job is to make your audience care about your obsessions," Springsteen says.
His recurring obsession is the life that he knew as a boy, the harsh relationship with his working class dad who didn't think much of a rock and roll son.
"It was a tough, struggling household. People struggled emotionally. People struggled financially to get through the day," Springsteen remembers. "Small town. Small town world which I continue to return to. It's like when I went to write, though, I put my father's clothes on. You know the immersement in that world through my parents and my own experience as a child and the need to tell a story that maybe was partially his. Or maybe a lot his. I just felt drawn to do it."
"Your dad wasn't all that proud of you as a young man?" Pelley asks.
"Oh, he was later. When I came home with the Oscar and I put it on the kitchen table, and he just looked at it and said, 'Bruce, I'll never tell anybody what to do ever again,'" Springsteen remembers, laughing. "It was like, that was his comment. So I said, 'Oh. That's okay.'"
The music that emerged from his upbringing was a kind of blue collar ballad set to rock and roll, Elvis meets Dylan, uniquely Springsteen. Much of the new music is a protest. Some of it blunt, as in the song that asks "Who will be the last to die for a mistake," but most of it subtle, like "Long Walk Home," the story of a man who returns to his all-American small town but doesn’t recognize it anymore.
"What's on your mind? What are you writing about?" Pelley asks.
"I guess I would say that what I do is I try to chart the distance between American ideals and American reality. That's how my music is laid out. It's like we've reached a point where it seems that we're so intent on protecting ourselves that we're willing to destroy the best parts of ourselves to do so," Springsteen says.
Asked what he means, Springsteen tells Pelley, "Well, I think that we've seen things happen over the past six years that I don't think anybody ever thought they'd ever see in the United States. When people think of the American identity, they don't think of torture. They don't think of illegal wiretapping. They don't think of voter suppression. They don't think of no habeas corpus. No right to a lawyer … you know. Those are things that are anti-American."
"You know, I think this record is going to be seen as anti-war. And you know there are people watching this interview who are going to say to themselves, 'Bruce Springsteen is no patriot,'" Pelley remarks.
"Well, that's just the language of the day, you know? The modus operandi for anybody who doesn't like somebody, you know, criticizing where we've been or where we're goin'," Springsteen says. "It's unpatriotic at any given moment to sit back and let things pass that are damaging to some place that you love so dearly. And that has given me so much. And that I believe in, I still feel and see us as a beacon of hope and possibility."
Springsteen sees himself following a long American tradition reaching back through Vietnam and on to the Great Depression.
"There's a part of the singer going way back in American history that is of course the canary in the coalmine. When it gets dark, you're supposed to be singing. It's dark right now," Springsteen says. "And so I went back to Woody Guthrie and Dylan and the people who said, say take Pete Seeger, who wants to know, doesn't want to know how this song sounds, he wants to know what's it for."
"What needs to be said, in this country at this moment, in your opinion, what needs to be said?" Pelley asks.
"I think we live in a time when what is true can be made to seem a lie," Springsteen says. "And what is lie can be made to seem true. And I think that the successful manipulation of those things have characterized several of our past elections. That level of hubris and arrogance has got us in the mess that we're in right now. And we're in a mess. But if we subvert, the best things that we're about in the name of protecting our freedoms, if we remove them, then who are we becoming, you know? Who are we, you know? The American idea is a beautiful idea. It needs to be preserved, served, protected and sung out. Sung out on a nightly basis. That's what I'm going to try to do."
###
This segment was originally broadcast on Oct. 7, 2007. It was updated on July 25, 2008.
- Login or register to post comments
- Email this page
- Printer-friendly version
- Spotlight this page



The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison
Nonviolent Struggle: 50 Crucial Points
George W. Bush, War Criminal?: The Bush Administration's Liability for 269 War Crimes
Nonviolence: Twenty-Five Lessons from the History of a Dangerous Idea
A Force More Powerful: A Century of Nonviolent Conflict
Waging Nonviolent Struggle: 20th Century Practice and 21st Century Potential
A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin Luther King, Jr.
The 35 Articles of Impeachment and the Case for Prosecuting George W. Bush
The Trial of Donald Rumsfeld
The Prosecution of George W. Bush for Murder
Cowboy Republic: Six Ways the Bush Gang Has Defied the Law
United States v. George W. Bush et al.
The Genius of Impeachment: The Founders' Cure for Royalism
Articles of Impeachment Against George W. Bush
The Impeachment of George W. Bush: A Practical Guide for Concerned Citizens
The Case for Impeachment
Impeach the President: The Case Against Bush and Cheney
George W. Bush versus the U.S. Constitution: The Downing Street Memos and Deception, Manipulation, Torture, Retribution, and Cover-ups in the Iraq War and Illegal Domestic Spying
Verdict and Findings of Fact
Impeach Bush: A Funny Li'l Graphical Novel About the Worstest Pres'dent in the History of Forevar
Pretensions to Empire: Notes on the Criminal Folly of the Bush Administration
The Twilight of Democracy: The Bush Plan for America













www.VelvetRevolution.us
It Is The Interviewer Who Should Be Seen As Unpatriotic
That interviewer is clueless when he asks Springsteen what he means. Springsteen I believe records under a record lable which is part of the CBS communications family. Thus Springsteen is a natural personality to be interviewed by the television network arm of the corporate body.
Having not witnessed the entire interview with the exception of this minute and a half clip, it would be helpful to see how this portion fit into the entire context of the interview.
It is painfully obvious to anyone with common sense and understanding of popular culture that Springsteen is an icon to a huge portion of the population. Springsteen understands this and when he says his music is intended to bridge the gap between American ideals and American reality, there can be no question as to what he means and why he writes his music to comment on this gap. His answer is quite clear and direct as he cites clear examples of manifestations of that problem over the last six years.
Is this interview done in the lead up to the political conventions calculated by one of the corporate giants benefitting from the gap between ideals and realities in America to discredit or marginalize one of its creative assets?
Read The Transcript Now
After reading the transcript of the entire interview, I stand on what I initially commented. The interviewer Pelley seems to have more been a provacateur with his question which is in the short clip I first commented upon. His entire context is much more palitable yet I still feel the manner of his question to Springsteen was calculated to elicit scornful views of the artist.
It kind of reminds me of a line in one of Springsteen's songs about how he and his friends learned more from a 3 minute record than they ever did in school. Springsteen and his cohorts have always been artists. They possessed gifts not available to others. When we all discover whatever gifts we as human beings have had bestowed upoin us, we can experience the ability to contribute.
Springsteen is able to make great contributions through his musical gifts while others in the population contribute in other ways such as in medicine, research, law, business and otehr pursuits. It is an ongoing developmental process. It is when someone or some group seeks to take a snapshot of what is at any given time and then seek to keep things in accordance with that snapshot that those problems Springsteen listed in his interview choke that natural progression which our founding fathers provided for in the Constitution.
Just Doing His Job
Sorry, Richard, I don't get the provocateur part about Pelley. His job as an interviewer is to feed Bruce questions to explain what he means, and Pelley did that. His question allowed Springsteen to draw the distinction between authentic patriotism and the faux palaber that over recent years is taken for "patriotism," and used as a wedge to ostracize anyone who doesn't buy the administration's line lock, stock and barrel.
For all we know, Pelley is a huge Springsteen fan, and gets him and what his music is about. I strongly agree with other things you've said; I just don't know how Pelley could have elicited the same response - an explanation - from Bruce without asking the question. And in the purest sense of the word, Pelley was to provoke a response. It gave Bruce a segue to cite a few specific examples of administration policies that are un-American - that is, that violate our authentic, traditional American principles and values.
As for CBS currently having Bruce under a recording contract, it would take me some more time to ferret that out. He did have a contract with CBS in 1972, but I don't know about now, so I can't address your speculation about discrediting Bruce prior to the conventions.
Criticism Accepted
As I alluded in my reply to my initial post, I was reacting, probably over reacting to the minute and a half clip before clicking on to make the comment.
It was not until after I made the first comment that I read the transcript of the interview. Yes, Pelley did provide Springsteen a platform upon which to eloquently state his views. Mr. Pelley has my regrets for jumping to unwarranted conclusions about his role.
I remain convinced that a corporate Goliath like CBS is not beyond making insinuations about any personality simply by asking such a loaded question. Why put such a personality into a defensive position in the first place. Even without the intent, it is clearly going to result in opportunities for cheap shot artists like O'Reilly and Limbaugh.
These types like nothing more than to feed their followers with canned hatred for anyone who has the ability to think for themselves and also the talent and ability to reach a mass audience effectively. Certainly Bruce Springsteen has the talent, audience and capability to effectively get his message to such a vast audience.
Again, i sincerely apologize for my initial rant on Mr. Pelley. Having read the transcript after the fact, I was compelled by my conscience to reply to myself. Thank you Chip also for the feedback as well.